Why Barclays still looks undervalued despite rising credit risks

Barclays combines strong capital returns, resilient trading income and cheap valuation, though rising impairments remain an uncomfortable warning signal.

Mark Rogers Mark Rogers

The Barclays (LSE: BARC) share price has already doubled over the past two years, yet I still think the market is underestimating how much cash this bank can return to shareholders. That may sound strange after a volatile first quarter and another jump in impairment charges, but Barclays increasingly looks like a bank moving from recovery mode into disciplined capital distribution.

Investors spent years treating Barclays as the awkward middle child of UK banking. The investment bank was viewed as too risky, UK consumer exposure looked vulnerable, and returns consistently lagged the best US lenders. That narrative has shifted sharply during the past 12 months as higher interest rates, stronger trading revenue and aggressive buybacks have transformed sentiment.

The most important development is not the quarterly earnings headline, it is management’s growing confidence around shareholder returns.

Barclays originally outlined plans to return at least £15bn to shareholders between 2024 and 2026 through dividends and buybacks, but management has since reinforced broader distribution ambitions stretching toward 2028.

That matters because Barclays still trades at a valuation that suggests investors do not fully trust those returns. The bank continues buying back stock aggressively, including a £1bn programme launched in February and another £500m programme announced after first-quarter results. If management keeps shrinking the share count while maintaining double-digit returns on tangible equity, earnings per share could keep climbing even without explosive revenue growth.

The investment bank also deserves more credit than it usually receives. First-quarter income surpassed £4bn for the first time, helped by stronger trading activity and rising equities revenue. Barclays will never dominate Wall Street in the same way as JPMorgan or Goldman Sachs, but it does not need to. The division simply needs to remain consistently profitable while the UK retail and corporate bank benefits from structurally higher interest income.

That combination is particularly useful in the current environment. Central banks are becoming more cautious about cutting rates as energy prices and geopolitical tensions threaten another inflation wave. Barclays itself recently shifted to expecting no US Federal Reserve rate cuts during 2026. Higher-for-longer rates are not universally positive for banks, but they do support lending margins and hedge income, especially for diversified lenders with large deposit bases.

Still, there are risks here that investors should not ignore. Barclays took a £228m hit linked to a securitised-products fraud case during the first quarter, while impairment charges climbed sharply. The bank also booked a further £105m provision tied to the Financial Conduct Authority’s motor finance review, highlighting that UK consumer finance risks have not disappeared.

Consumer spending trends already look shaky. Barclays data showed UK household spending falling for the first time since late 2024, with travel and discretionary purchases weakening noticeably. That does not automatically translate into a banking crisis, but it does suggest parts of the UK economy remain fragile beneath the surface.

Even so, I think the risk-reward balance still favours investors willing to look beyond the next quarter. Barclays has strengthened its capital position, its CET1 ratio remains comfortably above regulatory requirements, and management appears increasingly focused on delivering shareholder value rather than chasing empire-building expansion.

The shares no longer look absurdly cheap, but they still appear undervalued relative to the scale of cash returns likely over the next few years. Unless the UK economy deteriorates far more sharply than expected, I believe Barclays remains one of the more attractive large-cap banking plays in the FTSE 100.