Can Vodafone’s German turnaround justify a further rally?

Strong FY26 results and German recovery show promise, but stretched valuation and analyst caution suggest gains may already be priced in.

Mark Rogers Mark Rogers

Vodafone Group (LON: VOD) shares have recovered from their depths last May, rising nearly 65% to trade at 111.15p as of 17 May 2026. The pace of this rally has been brisk enough to catch many investors off guard – and raise questions about whether optimism has run too far, too fast.

The company’s turnaround case rests on solid foundations. Full-year results released on 12 May showed revenue climbing 8% to €40.5bn, whilst service revenue – a cleaner measure of underlying business performance – expanded 8.8% to €33.5bn.

What matters most is that Germany, Vodafone’s largest market and a persistent weakness, finally showed signs of stabilising. Service revenue in Germany declined just 0.2% for the full year, but crucially turned positive in the fourth quarter with 1.3% growth. This improvement materialised despite relentless mobile market competition and headwinds from television subscriber losses, suggesting management’s turnaround actions are beginning to bite.

Beyond Germany, Africa delivered organic growth of 12.9%, a clear area of strength in the portfolio. Digital services surged 14.2% across the group, demonstrating momentum in higher-margin connectivity solutions and cloud offerings. These are the growth drivers investors have been waiting for.

The company delivered adjusted EBITDA growth of 4.5% on an organic basis, hitting the upper end of management guidance. Critically, free cash flow reached €2.6bn, well above expectations and allowing Vodafone to complete a €2 billion share buyback whilst increasing its dividend by 2.5%.

What’s driving the share price momentum, though, is not just recent results. Deutsche Bank has raised its price target to 155 pence, whilst several analysts have upgraded their ratings in recent weeks ahead of the earnings release. The company also made a transformative move by agreeing to acquire CK Hutchison’s 49% stake in VodafoneThree for £4.3bn, consolidating full control of UK operations and promising £700m in annual savings by 2030.

Yet beneath the surface, there are reasons to temper enthusiasm. Consensus analyst sentiment remains at “Hold” across 16 covering analysts, with 5 Buys, 5 Holds and 6 Sells. This split view – far from a ringing endorsement – suggests the market is genuinely divided on whether recent momentum can be sustained.

At current levels, Vodafone trades at a modest discount to its European telecoms peers, but this discount may not be as compelling as it once appeared. The company’s organic service revenue growth of 5.4% remains solid but hardly exceptional in a competitive environment. Germany, whilst improving, remains in single-digit growth territory. Africa is vibrant, but it is a smaller part of the business than Europe and subject to currency volatility.

More concerning is the complexity of executing the VodafoneThree integration whilst simultaneously managing the Three UK buyout. Regulatory approval for the stake acquisition is not yet certain, and any delays or conditions imposed by authorities could disrupt management focus. UK regulatory scrutiny around mobile consolidation has been tightening, so risks here are genuine.

The buy-back activity and dividend increases are shareholder-friendly moves, but they can mask underlying operational challenges. If organic growth momentum stalls – particularly in Germany, where competitive pricing pressure remains intense – the company will have fewer levers to pull to support earnings-per-share growth.

Analysts appear to have recognised this tension. Recent commentary from some brokers suggests room for consolidation in the 110p-116p range before a sustained move higher. DZ Bank downgraded Vodafone to Hold from Buy on 14 May, citing concerns about execution risk and the company’s ability to deliver on ambitious cost targets.

For patient investors, the fundamentals have undoubtedly improved. A simplified operating structure, stronger cash generation and momentum in Africa represent genuine progress from the turnaround years of 2023-2025. The dividend now yields 2.5%, respectable by modern standards and above the FTSE 100 average.

Yet the sharp share price recovery has already rewarded early believers generously. The gap between current trading levels and analyst consensus price targets suggests limited further upside in the near term. Bullish price targets cluster around 155p, implying roughly 40% upside – but this is predicated on execution going precisely to plan over the next two years.

The shares appear fairly valued at present levels, with the recovery already largely reflected in current pricing. Investors may question whether fresh money now justifies entry ahead of greater clarity on the VodafoneThree integration, German market stabilisation, and evidence that high-margin digital services can accelerate further. For now, the outlook appears more balanced than decisively bullish.